Your search

Result 1 resource

  • This is a 16th–17th century apologetic treatise, authored by Jesuit Visitor Alessandro Valignano or an associate, in response to criticisms from Franciscan missionaries concerning the Society of Jesus’s activities in Japan and China. The document, preserved under archival reference 49-IV-58 at the Biblioteca da Ajuda (Lisbon), refutes claims made by Franciscans such as Fray Martín Ignacio de Loyola and Fray Jerónimo de Jesús regarding the legitimacy of the Jesuits’ exclusive missionary mandate, granted by Pope Gregory XIII in 1585 and supported by Portuguese royal authority. It defends the Jesuit practice of cultural adaptation—such as adopting local dress and language—as essential for evangelisation, contrasting it with the Franciscans’ confrontational methods, which allegedly provoked persecution under Toyotomi Hideyoshi (‘Taico Sama’). The text challenges accusations that the Jesuits obstructed other religious orders, monopolised trade via Macau, or engaged in political manipulation, asserting instead that their efforts sustained Christianity during severe repression. It further disputes claims about financial misconduct, arguing that Jesuit funding derived from limited alms and silk trade profits, not exploitation. Central to the argument is the assertion that Jesuit prudence preserved Christian communities, while the Franciscans’ imprudence led to martyrdom in 1597. Drawing on personal experience, correspondence, and theological reasoning, the author upholds the validity of papal and royal decrees restricting access to Japan, maintaining that unity among missionaries was vital for the faith’s survival in a politically volatile context.

Last update from database: 12/5/25, 4:01 AM (UTC)